US Default Inevitable: Fund Manager
Published: Wednesday, 13
Jul 2011 | 7:12 AM ET
By: Shai Ahmed
Associate Web Producer, CNBC.com
A U.S. default isn't a
matter of "if" but "when," David Murrin, chief
investment officer at Emergent Asset Management, told CNBC.
"It's inevitable that the U.S. will
default—it's essentially an empire which is overextended and in
decline—and that its financial system will go with it," he
The question is: Does
the U.S. default when it is forced to by the outside world, probably the
Chinese, or does it take the option to default on its own terms in such a
way that it may have a strategic advantage, Murrin said.
Republicans and Democrats
are currently locked in a debate on how to cut
the U.S. budget deficit, and on whether the $14.3 trillion debt ceiling
should be raised. Both parties need to come to a consensus by Aug. 2,
otherwise the country will be in a state of technical default.
In his book
"Breaking the Code of History," Murrin argues that the balance
of power has shifted away from the West, with America as the superpower,
towards the East, led by China.
He believes the U.S.
cannot afford to compete with the rise of Eastern powers.
"It's very simple,
its (America's) empire system, its financial system is in decline, we've
seen very little growth for over a decade apart from financial engineering
and leveraging, which ultimately caused the debt crisis of 2008,"
He argues that emerging markets have a distinct
advantage over more mature economies through demographics, working
dynamics, and the ability to create fundamental economic growth. This
imbalance inevitably pushes developed markets towards default.
"The only similar
example is Britain. It was once an empire and when it lost its power over
(the Suez Canal crisis of 1956) it had a large amount of loans outstanding
to the Empire, and America owned most of that," Murrin said.
"That was the power America had over Britain and it ended the pound,
but their values were very similar in terms of global geo-politics and the
world didn't really change that much."
He called America the
last of the Christian, Western empires. "Who do you pass your values
to as China grows and challenges? No one. So you are forced to continue to
spend and one day you cannot afford it," Murrin added.
"If you look at how
China is seeking to control debt in Europe and marginal debt in the U.S.,
which is strategic ownership, the position becomes more precarious for
America," he said. "If I was an American in the White House, I'd
feel safe militarily but fiscally I am very vulnerable."
"China is expanding
its navy at a staggering rate, there is a whole naval arms race that is
happening at a staggering rate and that will have ramifications within
years," Murrin said. "It is a military dictatorship—look
at the People's Liberation Army which really has control and it is very,
"We (in Europe)
have tried to regain empire through Europe (through a) forced
regionalization process which was bound to fail," he said. "The
U.S.'s options are pretty dire and this is a real disaster but you can
The real disaster,
Murrin said, would be to avoid recognizing the collapse of America's
powerbase. "That only accelerates the loss of power and that creates
a bigger vacuum, which China moves into and leads to potential
conflict," he said.
For investors wondering
where to look in this environment, Murrin said one thing is clear:
"You probably shouldn't own dollar-denominated assets."
© 2011 CNBC.com