There is little point rehearsing the stale debate over whether Club Med
states are to blame for living beyond their means, or whether Germany is
as much to blame for beggar-thy-neighbour mercantilism, and for flooding
the South with excess capital. Both played a role, and much else
besides.
What is clear is that these imbalances have built up to such a degree
that the Greco-Latin bloc is now trapped in debt-deflation – like
victims of the 1930s Gold Standard – with wage costs out of kilter
by 20pc or more.
Equally clear is that Germany cannot cling to a structural trade
surplus with all southern Europe in perpetuity, at least on this scale.
The system has to balance over time. Germany must either give up its
intra-EMU surplus, or furnish offsetting funds through capital flows or
fiscal transfers, if it wishes to preserve the euro. It is the complete
refusal of Germany’s governing class to face up to this dilemma
that is now destroying monetary union. Firewalls are a decoy.
So EMU grinds on, a contraction machine for half a dozen countries,
with France sliding slowly into this assembly of Miserables. To impose
net fiscal tightening of 3pc a year or more on the South at this stage
– without offsetting monetary stimulus or demand growth in the
North – can lead only to a downward spiral that engulfs everybody
in the end.
“Rather than admit that they’ve been wrong, European
leaders seem determined to drive their economy — and their society
— off a cliff,” said Professor Krugman.
Hopes that structural reforms in Spain, Italy, Portugal, and Greece
will save the day are likely to be dashed on the jagged reefs of
politics long before any benefit is visible, a decade hence at best.
The Flores de Lemus Foundation thinks Spanish unemployment will reach
six million by next year, or 26pc. The regions will bear the brunt of
cuts, and there lies a political minefield since Catalan nationalists
are convinced that the Partido Popular of Mariano Rajoy is exploiting
the crisis to reorder Spain’s constitutional landscape. This adds
nitroglycerine to the mix.
In Greece, investors fret over whether Pasok and New Democracy can
between them muster a governing coalition willing to comply with the
EU-IMF “Memorandum”. We will find out in May, but it is a
red herring in any case. Even if they can form a government, they must
agree to cuts equal to 5pc of GDP for the 2013 and 2014 budgets by a
deadline in June, and then start delivering on these cuts. Pasok leader
Evangelos Venizelos is already asking for an extra year.
These fiscal targets will not be met. The slippage will be so obvious
within months that German and Dutch patience will snap. And then what?
In France, the austerity debate is at least joined. François
Hollande has forsworn the EU fiscal compact and called on the European
Central Bank to underwrite Club Med bond markets – with the risk
squarely on its own balance sheet. He has stiffened his rhetoric after
losing support to crypto-revolutionary Jean-Luc Melenchon, whose vow
“to smash the Merkozy axis” has struck home on the hustings.
Whether Mr Hollande has the imagination or mettle to break the
half-century mould of EU politics and lead a “pro-growth”
Latin revolt remains to be seen. Events may precipitate rupture in any
case if his other-worldly policies – including a CUT in the state
retirement age to 60 – sets off the sort of speculative attack
seen when François Mitterrand won in 1981. The Paris bourse fell
18pc the next day. Stress today would surface in the bond market, where
France has no margin for error.
Italy and Spain have already lost that margin. Pimco’s Mohamed
El-Erian is still buying their debt – or claims he is – but
most `real money’ behemoths, from Japanese life insurers to
petro-wealth funds, have made a strategic decision to stay clear until
EU leaders either “put up” with genuine fiscal union, or
`break up’ with a cathartic release from the current hopeless
state of affairs.
In such circumstances, incremental rescues by the EU and IMF are worse
than useless. By refusing to take loses themselves they subordinate
other creditors, pushing them deeper into “mezzanine status”
with each intervention. This is no longer theoretical after
Merkozy’s 75pc haircut for holders of Greek debt, many of them
pension funds who purchased in good faith. Expropriated once, shame on
you. Expropriated twice, shame on me.
Spanish and Italian banks are now sole chief buyers of their own
countries’ bonds, playing the “carry trade” with money
from the ECB’s three-year loans. This is a dangerous game. The
latest surge in yields leaves many sitting on paper losses that they may
have to crystalize.
Week by week, the fortunes of prostrate states and prostrate banks are
becoming more intimately entwined. Systemic risk is rising by leaps and
bounds.
This is not to criticize the ECB’s Mario Draghi for his blast of
liquidity. He had no choice. The Club Med banking system was
disintegrating last November. But piecemeal intervention – or
“limited and temporary”, as he puts it – is
self-defeating.
Central banks have to take the risk onto their own balance sheets, not
fob it off onto distressed lenders. They must act with overwhelming
force, taking the possibility of sovereign defaults off the table
entirely.
The ECB has not done so. Doubts are fanned daily by the Bundesbank. The
body-language is awful. And hawks are already itching to tighten again,
an astonishing prospect given the collapse real M1 deposits across the
eurozone’s arc of depression – now falling at double-digit
rates even in Italy.
China, Japan, America, the oil powers, and the rising economies of
Latin America had a chance to pull Europe back from suicide through IMF
pressure. The world dropped the ball.